If you have Cash App on your phone, you have likely stared at that little "Bitcoin" tab and wondered: Should I?

It is incredibly tempting. You already use the app to split dinner bills or pay your roommate for rent. Why not buy $50 of Bitcoin while you're there?

But is it actually safe? Is it a "real" crypto exchange? And are you getting ripped off on fees?

The short answer is: Yes, it is safe. But it might not be the smartest place to keep your money long-term.

Here is our 2025 review of buying Bitcoin on Cash App, and when you should graduate to a dedicated exchange like Coinbase or Gemini.

The Safety Verdict: Is Your Bitcoin Secure?

In the early days, Cash App was just a peer-to-peer money transfer tool. Today, it is a financial giant owned by Block, Inc. (a publicly traded company).

From a security standpoint, Cash App is surprisingly robust:

  • Cold Storage: They state that the vast majority of their Bitcoin is held in "cold storage" (offline), meaning hackers cannot access it via the internet.
  • Regulation: Unlike offshore exchanges that might vanish overnight, Cash App is heavily regulated in the US.
  • Withdrawals: Crucially, Cash App allows you to withdraw your Bitcoin to your own private wallet. This is the hallmark of a legitimate exchange. If you can't move it, you don't own it. On Cash App, you can.

The Risk: The biggest risk isn't Cash App getting hacked; it's you getting hacked. Because Cash App is linked to your email or phone number, if a scammer gets access to your phone, they can drain your funds.

Pro Tip: If you hold Bitcoin on Cash App, go to your settings and enable "Security Lock" immediately. This forces FaceID or a PIN for every single transaction.

The Cost: The "Convenience Tax"

Safety isn't the problem with Cash App. Fees are.

Cash App charges a "convenience fee" for every purchase, plus a "spread" (a markup on the price of Bitcoin).

  • The Spread: If Bitcoin is trading at $100,000, Cash App might show you a price of $101,000. That difference is their profit.
  • The Fee: On top of the spread, they charge a service fee.

For a $20 purchase, this might only be $0.50. You won't notice it. But if you are buying $1,000 or more, you are likely overpaying significantly compared to dedicated crypto exchanges.

The Alternatives: When to "Graduate"

Cash App is perfect for beginners buying $50 here and there. But once you get serious, you need a specialized platform. Here are the two best alternatives.

1. Coinbase (Best for Trust & Ease)

Coinbase is the gold standard for US investors. It is a public company and the most trusted name in the space.

  • Why switch: They offer Coinbase Advanced, a professional trading interface with significantly lower fees (often 0.4% to 0.6%) compared to the retail apps.
  • Safety Upgrade: Coinbase offers "Vault" protection and supports hardware security keys (YubiKey), making it much harder for hackers to steal your funds than a phone-based app like Cash App.

2. Gemini (Best for Security Junkies)

Founded by the Winklevoss twins, Gemini built its entire reputation on one word: Trust.

  • Why switch: Gemini is a New York Trust company regulated by the NYSDFS (one of the strictest regulators in the world).
  • The Feature: Like Coinbase, they have an "ActiveTrader" mode that offers much cheaper fees than their standard app.
  • Safety Upgrade: Gemini requires strict identity verification and has insurance coverage for digital assets held in their hot wallet.

Final Verdict: Who Is Cash App For?

  • Stick with Cash App if: You are a complete beginner who wants to buy $20 of Bitcoin for fun, or you want to "auto-invest" your spare change. The convenience is worth the slightly higher fee.
  • Move to Coinbase or Gemini if: You plan to invest over $500, or you want to set up a serious, long-term crypto portfolio with lower fees and better security features.

The Golden Rule: No matter where you buy—Cash App, Coinbase, or Gemini—never leave large amounts of money on the exchange. Buy it, and then move it to a self-custody wallet (like the Robinhood Wallet we discussed or a hardware wallet) for safekeeping.